True Christianity

(Click here for a video of John reading this Catch.)


In a 2017 article in the New York Times Rod Dreher raises an effective argument that American Christianity is actually not true Christianity. Now this is certainly not a new idea, nor is it something we haven’t discussed quite often here at the Catch. In fact, our “Declaration of a Marketplace Christian” is in many ways an attempt to identify and correct what has gone wrong with American Christianity.  Dreher holds that American Christianity is not “historical” or “biblical;” it’s spiritually thin; and it has sold its soul to politics.

In his article he mentions that Christian Smith, a sociologist at Notre Dame who has been studying the religious and spiritual lives of Millennials, has come up with a new name for American Christianity: Moralistic Therapeutic Deism or M.T.D..

“Moralistic Therapeutic Deism is a pseudoreligion” he writes, “that jettisons the doctrines of historical biblical Christianity and replaces them with feel-good, vaguely spiritual nostrums. In M.T.D., the highest goal of the religious life is being happy and feeling good about oneself. It’s the perfect religion for a self-centered, consumerist culture. But it is not Christianity.”

In his article, Dreher goes on to conclude that if Christianity is to survive, it needs to chart a new (or is it old?) course, not the one currently traveled by evangelical Christianity in America — indeed, in most churches. And since a majority of Millennials have rejected church but are still seeking spiritual answers, the scene is set for a true spiritual revolution.

This kind of stuff makes my spine tingle, because this is exactly what we are championing here at the Catch, and what we are seeking to help foster. And just like the Jesus movement of the early ‘70s, it will begin outside the existing structures of religion and the institutional church, and whether it will make its way back into that church remains to be seen, but it is not the point. The point is to follow the Spirit of God, and we believe the Spirit of God is leading us into a new frontier — a group of believers following the Christ of the gospels (what Tony Campolo calls “Red Letter Christians”) and committed to discipleship and administering Grace Turned Outward to everyone we touch. It is Christians, not trying to save western civilization, not trying to be happy and feel good about ourselves, but to follow Christ and survive as communities of believers loving one another, caring for the needy and keeping ourselves from being corrupted by the world, regardless of whether the civilization and culture around us collapses.

As James instructed us in James 1:27, “Pure and genuine religion in the sight of God the Father means caring for orphans and widows in their distress and refusing to let the world corrupt you.”

This entry was posted in Christianity and politics, Marketplace Christian, Worldview and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to True Christianity

  1. Lisa says:


  2. Toni Petrella says:

    First, I am amazed at all the labels out there to describe what should be the most important relationship each of us can have with God thru our Savior Jesus Christ and each day trying to walk with him better than the day before so we grow stronger spiritually inside and out and I believe if this is emphasized with millions one at a time different ages we just might have that gathering of folks all over in that strong relationship with our Lord and Savior and need not any label on this one.

  3. Mark D Seguin says:

    Excuse me Pastor John I could be wrong, SURELY have been before even though I believe I understand the Spirit of Today’s Catch, or at least the Scripture used at the end; James 1:27, YET your use of Tony Campolo (TC) quote of “Red Letter Christians” is almost a bit of a joke!

    Why, very simply I can easily remember him (TC) being on Larry King and him NOT wanting to agree with one word of Jerry Farewell (which I kind of understand, LOL) But when Jerry Farewell said and quoted the Gospel, that Jesus is the ONLY way to enter God’s Paradise (John 14:6) Tony C. said or more or less he didn’t agree….

    And it was SO EASILY understood, by me & almost everyone watching & SURELY everyone I spoke to about watching that Show b/c we had Tony C. preach one Sunday morning @ our Church, Kensington Community Church (A Willow Creek Movement Church) BUT EVERYONE agreed b/c he was a bit too self righteous & didn’t want to give one inch to Jerry Farewell… and I think / believe that’s sad & Jesus said it a great Red Letter verse!!!

  4. jwfisch says:

    Mark: Tony is a dear friend of mine and an incredible representative of the gospel of Jesus Christ in the marketplace. I might not agree with him on every point, but I love his use of “Red Letter Christian” to represent the centrality of the words of Jesus in our focus on the truth. That is the only part of Tony I was focusing on here.

    • Mark D Seguin says:

      I agree w/ you Pastor John – no one is perfect 100% of the time and I don’t agree with anyone all of the times. As you SURELY know…! Yet what he, Tony C. did on National TV on the Larry King show NEEDS to discussed! And NOT just thrown under the carpet!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.